By Karen Auge, Denver
Post Medical Writer via
Checkbiotech
A French company can grow the state's first produce destined
for the medicine cabinet - a test crop of pharmaceutical corn -
on 30 acres somewhere in Phillips County, the
Colorado State Agriculture
Department decided Wednesday.
The recommendation, by a three-member review panel, paves the
way for Meristem
Therapeutics to plant genetically modified corn in far
northeast Colorado.
It comes despite objections from some farmers and
environmental groups who worry the corn will contaminate other
crops.
The corn will contain a protein, lipase, that will be used in
an experimental drug researchers hope will help patients with
cystic fibrosis.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture gave preliminary approval
to Meristem's plans this spring. The state technically could not
have blocked the planting after the federal agency approved it.
But the state could, and did, add conditions before giving its
blessing.
The state is insisting that its inspectors be allowed to
accompany USDA officials on visits to the site. The state also
wants to be allowed to visit the cornfield without advanced
warning.
"I'm convinced that production of pharmaceuticals using
biotechnology can be accomplished in Colorado safely and without
threat to our agricultural markets or to the consumer of our
food products," said Don Ament, the state's agriculture
commissioner.
But ever since the company filed its application with the
state last month, the prospect of a "biopharm" cornfield rising
out of northeastern Colorado soil has pitted the state's
agricultural powerhouses against each other and made strange
bedfellows of traditional and organic farmers and environmental
groups that oppose the idea.
Opponents charge that Colorado doesn't have any procedure for
evaluating the safety or potential risks of biopharm crops, and
that the crops will contaminate the environment and possibly
other crops.
"What we're asking for is a moratorium on biopharm crops
until an open and public process can determine that they're
safe," Peter Crowell of the Western Colorado Congress said
Wednesday before the approval was announced. "We're not saying
we want a ban."
But those backing Meristem's plans say biopharms could spark
Colorado's sputtering economy.
The biopharm industry is ready to explode, said Jared Fiel of
Colorado Corn, which represents many of the growers who produced
more than 1.1 million acres of corn in Colorado in 2000.
"Colorado could be the Silicon Valley in that process," Fiel
said.
Officials at Meristem, which has offices in Massachusetts,
did not respond to request for comment. The company has not
publicly disclosed the exact location of the acres it is
leasing, citing fears of vandalism.
The USDA requires a 1-mile buffer between pharmaceutical corn
and the nearest field of ordinary corn.
That's small comfort, opponents say.
"We've been having mud rains out here this spring," Crowell
said. "We have quite a few organic farmers in the valley. Think
about what happens if we have a mud rain and that corn gets
contaminated."
Many of the opponents' concerns stem from problems in other
states. Last year, 50,000 bushels of soybeans had to be
destroyed in Nebraska after they were contaminated by
pharmaceutical corn. And the USDA ordered 155 acres of corn in
Iowa incinerated because pollen from genetically altered corn
had drifted into nearby fields.
But Meristem has told the state that the corn it plants will
be "sterilized," so the pharmaceutical seed cannot spread to
neighboring cornfields.