Exeter, United Kingdom
May 31, 2007Field trials
could be underestimating the potential for cross-pollination
between GM and conventional crops, according to new research by
the
University of Exeter. The research team recommends a
new method for predicting the potential for cross-pollination,
which takes account of wind speed and direction.
The research, funded by the
Natural Environment Research
Council (NERC) and published today (1 June 2007) in the
journal
Ecological Applications, used records of wind speed and
direction from weather stations across Europe to predict the
movement of pollen in the air. The findings show huge variation
in the amount of cross-pollination between GM and non-GM crops
of maize, oilseed rape, rice and sugar beet. Levels vary
according to whether the GM field is upwind or downwind of the
non-GM field given the direction of the prevailing wind over the
flowering period of the crop.
Field trials are regularly
carried out to measure the potential for cross-pollination
between GM and conventional crops. Current guidelines for
minimum field-to-field distances are based on the results from
these trials. However, if the GM field in a trial is downwind of
the non-GM field, the trial will underestimate the potential for
cross-pollination.
'We were struck by the strong
influence of wind direction on the amount of cross-pollination',
said Martin Hoyle of the University of Exeter. 'Wind speed and
direction are important factors outside of our control that have
not previously been used to inform guidelines on minimum
field-to-field distances. Recommended minimum distances between
GM and conventional crops may need to be increased based on our
findings.'
Field trials are time-consuming
and expensive, so measuring the potential for cross-pollination
across the full range of weather conditions is not feasible.
This research resulted in the development of a theoretical
computer model to analyse the effects of wind on pollen travel.
The model, together with measurements of cross-pollination and
wind speed and direction from field trials, can be used to
predict cross-pollination at other times and sites.
'If the production of GM crops
becomes widespread in Europe, it is essential that measures are
taken to minimise cross-pollination from GM to conventional
non-GM crops,' said Hoyle. 'The recommended minimum distances
between GM and conventional crops should be informed by weather
data, which is possible using our model of pollen dispersal in
the wind.'
The Natural Environment
Research Council funds world-class science, in universities and
its own research centres, that increases knowledge and
understanding of the natural world. NERC is tackling the 21st
century's major environmental issues such as climate change,
biodiversity and natural hazards. It leads in providing
independent research and training in the environmental sciences.
www.nerc.ac.uk
Ecological Applications is
the journal of the Ecological Society of America. |